The Payments Stock That Checks Every Buffett Box: ACI Worldwide's Perfect 9/9

What Is ACI Worldwide?

ACI Worldwide is one of the original players in electronic payments infrastructure. Founded in 1975, the company provides software that powers real-time payments, fraud detection, and payment processing for banks, merchants, and payment service providers across more than 95 countries. If you've ever made a real-time bank transfer, paid a bill electronically, or completed a point-of-sale transaction, there's a decent chance ACI's technology was involved somewhere in the chain.

The revenue model is a mix of recurring software licenses, SaaS subscriptions, and transaction-based processing fees. ACI has been shifting toward a more recurring revenue base as it transitions legacy on-premise customers to cloud-hosted solutions. In fiscal 2024, the company generated $1.59 billion in revenue — up 9.8% year-over-year — with $260.9 million in net income, a 67% jump from the prior year.

ACI's competitive position rests on deep integration. Its payment orchestration platform sits at the core of mission-critical systems for major financial institutions, and switching costs are significant. Once a bank builds its payment rails on ACI's software, ripping it out is expensive and risky. This creates the kind of customer stickiness that Buffett's framework is designed to identify.

How ACI Worldwide Scores on All 9 Buffettology Criteria

ACI Worldwide earns a perfect 9/9 on the Buffettology scoring system. Here's how it performs on each criterion.

1. High Return on Equity — PASS (18.1%)

Buffettology requires ROE above 12%. ACI's 18.1% ROE clears the threshold by a comfortable margin. This figure reflects the company's improving profitability — net income jumped 67% in fiscal 2024 as operating leverage kicked in from the subscription transition. An 18% ROE isn't eye-popping by software standards, but it signals a business that is efficiently converting equity into earnings.

2. High Return on Invested Capital — PASS (11.3%)

ROIC measures how well a company uses all its capital — debt plus equity — to generate returns. The threshold is 9%. ACI's 11.3% ROIC demonstrates that even when accounting for its debt load, the company generates returns above its cost of capital. This metric has been improving as the higher-margin subscription revenue ramps up.

3. Cash Machine — PASS (11.3% FCF/Assets)

This criterion checks whether the company generates meaningful free cash flow relative to its asset base. ACI's 11.3% ratio comfortably exceeds the 5% threshold. The payments software business generates strong operating cash flow with moderate capital expenditure requirements, allowing the company to convert a substantial portion of its revenue into cash.

4. Fair Valuation — PASS (6.4% Earnings Yield)

The earnings yield (inverse of P/E) must exceed 3.5%. ACI's 6.4% earnings yield clears this bar easily, meaning the business earns significantly more per dollar of market cap than a risk-free Treasury bond. With a trailing P/E around 16.9x, ACI trades at a deep discount to the Software Infrastructure industry average of roughly 35x — signaling that the market has yet to fully price in the company's earnings trajectory.

5. Share Buybacks — PASS (-2.8% Share Dilution)

Buffett favors companies that shrink their share count rather than diluting shareholders. ACI's shares outstanding are declining at 2.8% annually, demonstrating that management is returning capital through repurchases. While not as aggressive as some buyback programs, a steady reduction in share count compounds earnings-per-share growth over time.

6. Defensible Moat — PASS (49.7% Gross Margin)

Gross margins above 40% indicate pricing power and a competitive moat. ACI's 49.7% gross margin clears the threshold, reflecting the software-driven economics of its business. While not as high as pure SaaS companies, this margin is notable for a business that also operates payment processing infrastructure. The margin demonstrates that ACI's products command pricing that competitors can't easily undercut — a hallmark of switching-cost-driven moats.

7. Simple Business — PASS

ACI operates in the Technology sector with a straightforward value proposition: it builds software that moves money. Banks, billers, and merchants use ACI's platforms to process payments, detect fraud, and manage transactions. There's no speculative element — electronic payments are a core function of the global financial system, and demand grows as economies digitize.

8. Conservative Debt — PASS (0.62x Debt/Equity)

The threshold is 1.5x. ACI's 0.62x debt-to-equity ratio is well within conservative territory — less than half the maximum allowed by the Buffettology framework. This is a meaningful strength. The company has deleveraged significantly in recent years, giving it financial flexibility to invest in growth or weather economic downturns without balance sheet stress.

9. Consistent Growth — PASS (233.6% Five-Year Growth)

Five-year net income growth must be positive. ACI's 233.6% cumulative growth is exceptional — driven by the combination of revenue growth, margin expansion from the subscription transition, and operational discipline. This kind of earnings trajectory demonstrates a business that is fundamentally improving, not just riding a cyclical wave.

The Bull Case

ACI Worldwide has several structural tailwinds that bulls see driving continued value creation:

Real-time payments adoption is accelerating globally. Central banks and regulators worldwide are pushing for real-time payment infrastructure. ACI powers real-time payment systems in multiple countries, and every new market that adopts instant payments represents a growth opportunity. The company's December 2025 report highlighted that real-time payment demand is a key industry catalyst heading into 2026.

The subscription transition is unlocking margin expansion. As ACI shifts customers from legacy on-premise licenses to cloud-hosted SaaS solutions, recurring revenue grows and margins improve. The 67% jump in net income in fiscal 2024 is early evidence of this operating leverage. As the transition matures, margins should continue to expand.

Valuation is deeply discounted. At 16.9x trailing earnings and roughly 13.3x forward earnings, ACI trades at less than half the Software Infrastructure industry average of 34.9x. Simply Wall Street analysis suggests the stock trades more than 20% below fair value. For a company growing earnings at this pace, the discount is striking.

Conservative balance sheet provides optionality. With just 0.62x debt-to-equity, ACI has significant financial flexibility. Management can pursue strategic acquisitions, accelerate buybacks, or invest in R&D without stretching the balance sheet. This is a luxury that many software companies — burdened by acquisition-fueled debt — don't have.

Analyst consensus is unanimously bullish. All four covering analysts rate ACIW a Strong Buy, with a consensus price target of $62.50 — implying nearly 50% upside from current levels. Price targets range from $60 to $77.

The Bear Case

ACI faces legitimate challenges that investors should weigh honestly:

Organic growth has historically lagged expectations. ACI's revenue growth has been inconsistent over the past decade, with periods of stagnation and reliance on non-recurring license fees. While the subscription transition should stabilize revenue, the company needs to prove it can sustain mid-to-high single-digit organic growth consistently.

Industry disruption is real. ACI itself warned in December 2025 that payments leaders are "unprepared for structural disruption" from AI advancements, new regulatory frameworks, and the rapid expansion of real-time payments. While ACI is positioned to benefit from these trends, the company also faces the risk that nimbler fintech competitors or big-tech entrants could disrupt its position.

Revenue mix creates volatility. ACI's revenue historically includes lumpy, non-recurring software license fees that can swing quarterly results. This makes it harder for investors to model the business and can lead to earnings surprises — both positive and negative.

Macro headwinds could squeeze customers. Financial institutions are ACI's primary customers. In a macroeconomic downturn, banks and payment processors may delay technology spending, push back on contract renewals, or demand pricing concessions. ACI's revenue is ultimately tied to the health of the financial services sector.

The "Rule of 40" bar is rising. ACI's own industry analysis flagged that in 2026, "growth and margin will matter more than hype" — with the Rule of 40 (revenue growth plus profit margin) becoming a stricter valuation filter. ACI will need to demonstrate that its growth-plus-margin profile meets this increasingly demanding standard.

Valuation Overview

ACI Worldwide's current valuation looks compelling relative to both its history and peers:

Trailing P/E: 16.9x vs. Software Infrastructure average of ~35x
Forward P/E: 13.3x
Price-to-Sales: ~2.5x
EV/Revenue: ~3.2x
Earnings Yield: 6.4%
Market Cap: $4.32 billion
52-Week Range: $38.89 – $58.14

The stock is currently trading near the bottom of its 52-week range, down roughly 21.6% from its highs. Analyst price targets range from $60 to $77, with a consensus of $62.50 — implying 49% upside. Simply Wall Street's fair value analysis suggests ACIW is trading at a P/E of 20.1x versus an estimated fair P/E of 25.3x, indicating the stock is undervalued by more than 20%.

Compared to peers in the payments software space, ACI trades at a significant discount. The US Software industry average P/E is 34.9x, and the peer average is 29.5x. Even applying a conservative multiple to ACI's forward earnings of roughly $2.85 per share suggests meaningful upside from current levels.

The Buffettology Verdict

ACI Worldwide's perfect 9/9 Buffettology score reflects a business that hits every mark Buffett's framework demands: strong and improving returns on capital, a moat built on switching costs, conservative leverage, disciplined buybacks, and exceptional earnings growth. The 233.6% five-year earnings growth and 0.62x debt-to-equity ratio are particular standouts.

The central question for investors is whether ACI's subscription transition can sustain this earnings trajectory, or whether historical patterns of uneven growth will reassert themselves. The valuation — at roughly half the industry average P/E — suggests the market is skeptical. If ACI delivers on its recurring revenue potential and continues expanding margins, the current price could represent a meaningful disconnect between quality and valuation.

Want to see ACI Worldwide's live Buffettology score with the latest data? Check ACIW on Buffett Score.

Looking for more stocks that score 9/9? Download the Vetted app to explore detailed Buffettology analysis across thousands of stocks, plus scores from multiple expert investment strategies.