Acushnet's Quiet Moat: Why Buffett's Framework Gives the Titleist Parent a Perfect 9/9

What Is Acushnet Holdings?

Acushnet Holdings Corp. is the parent company behind some of golf's most iconic brands: Titleist, FootJoy, and Scotty Cameron. The company designs, manufactures, and distributes golf balls, golf clubs, golf shoes, gloves, and accessories. If you've watched any PGA Tour coverage, you've seen its products — 73% of PGA Tour players use a Titleist Pro V1 or Pro V1x ball, and Scotty Cameron putters hold a 52.6% share of the premium putter market.

The business generates roughly $2.46 billion in annual revenue across four primary segments. Titleist golf balls are the largest revenue driver at over $760 million, followed by FootJoy golf wear at nearly $600 million. The remainder comes from Titleist golf clubs, gear, and other branded accessories. Acushnet went public on the NYSE under the ticker GOLF in 2016 and has built a reputation for steady, premium-focused execution ever since.

Acushnet's competitive position is unusually strong for a consumer products company. Titleist holds a 47.2% share of the premium golf ball market. FootJoy commands 65.3% of premium golf footwear. These aren't narrow leads — they're dominant market positions built over decades of product quality, professional tour validation, and brand loyalty. The company doesn't chase trends or discount aggressively; it competes on performance and prestige, which gives it the kind of pricing power that Warren Buffett looks for in a business.

How Acushnet Scores on All 9 Buffettology Criteria

Acushnet earns a perfect 9/9 on the Buffettology scoring system. Here's how it performs on each criterion.

1. High Return on Equity — PASS (27.7%)

Buffettology requires ROE above 12%. Acushnet's 27.7% ROE is more than double the threshold — impressive for a manufacturing-heavy business that produces physical goods and manages global supply chains. This signals that Acushnet's brand premium and operational discipline translate directly into outsized returns on shareholder equity. Premium pricing and efficient capital deployment make this a business that earns far more per dollar of equity than most consumer companies.

2. High Return on Invested Capital — PASS (12.8%)

ROIC measures how efficiently a company uses all capital — debt and equity combined — to generate returns. The threshold is 9%. Acushnet's 12.8% ROIC confirms that the company creates genuine economic value above its cost of capital. Every dollar invested in manufacturing, R&D, and distribution earns a meaningful return, which is the hallmark of a well-run business with a durable competitive advantage.

3. Cash Machine — PASS (7.8% FCF/Assets)

This criterion checks whether a company generates strong free cash flow relative to its total assets. The threshold is 5%. Acushnet's 7.8% ratio indicates a business that reliably converts revenue into cash — not just accounting earnings. That cash funds dividends, buybacks, and reinvestment without requiring external financing or balance sheet strain.

4. Fair Valuation — PASS (3.8% Earnings Yield)

The earnings yield (the inverse of P/E) must exceed 3.5%. Acushnet's 3.8% earnings yield clears the bar, corresponding to a trailing P/E of roughly 26x. This is a tight pass — the stock isn't cheap — but it still generates enough earnings per dollar of market cap to satisfy Buffett's valuation floor. Investors are paying a fair price for quality, not a bargain basement price.

5. Share Buybacks — PASS (-5.5% Share Count Change)

Buffett favors companies that shrink their share count rather than diluting shareholders. Acushnet's share count is declining at 5.5% annually, one of the more aggressive buyback programs among mid-cap consumer companies. Management clearly prioritizes returning cash to shareholders, and a shrinking share base provides a built-in tailwind to earnings per share growth on top of organic business growth.

6. Defensible Moat — PASS (44.0% Gross Margin)

Gross margins above 40% indicate pricing power and a durable competitive moat. Acushnet's 44.0% gross margin clears the threshold, reflecting the premium pricing its brands command. When nearly half of every revenue dollar remains after cost of goods, it signals that customers value the product enough to pay well above commodity prices — and that competitors can't easily undercut the brand on price alone.

7. Simple Business — PASS

Acushnet operates in the Consumer Cyclical sector with a straightforward business model: design premium golf equipment and apparel, manufacture it to exacting quality standards, and sell it through pro shops, sporting goods retailers, and direct channels. There are no complex financial instruments, no speculative technology bets, and no conglomerate sprawl. It's a focused business that's done essentially the same thing for decades.

8. Conservative Debt — PASS (1.06x Debt/Equity)

The threshold is 1.5x. Acushnet's debt-to-equity ratio of 1.06x provides comfortable margin. The company recently completed a debt refinancing, and its leverage remains well within bounds for a manufacturing business with consistent cash flows. Conservative debt levels give Acushnet the flexibility to invest through economic downturns and continue returning capital to shareholders.

9. Consistent Growth — PASS (110.7% Five-Year Growth)

Five-year net income growth must be positive. Acushnet's 110.7% cumulative growth over five years means the company has more than doubled its bottom line in half a decade. This reflects both the sustained post-pandemic golf participation boom and the company's ability to raise prices without losing volume — a combination driven by brand strength and product quality.

The Bull Case

Golf participation remains elevated. Rounds played in the U.S. continue to run well above pre-COVID norms, according to National Golf Foundation data. The pandemic brought millions of new and returning golfers into the sport, and retention rates have been stronger than many expected. For a company that sells consumable products (golf balls wear out), sustained participation directly supports recurring revenue.

Dominant market share provides pricing power. Titleist's 47.2% premium golf ball market share and FootJoy's 65.3% premium footwear share aren't positions that competitors can easily erode. Professional tour validation — 73% of PGA Tour players use Titleist balls — creates aspirational demand among recreational golfers. This brand gravity gives Acushnet pricing power that most consumer companies lack, and it's a key reason gross margins hold above 40%.

Aggressive buybacks accelerate shareholder returns. With the share count declining at 5.5% annually, Acushnet is compounding EPS growth faster than underlying business growth. Management's commitment to capital returns signals confidence in the durability of cash flows and provides a margin of safety for investors even if top-line growth moderates.

Revenue growth is surprising to the upside. Stronger-than-expected revenue growth through 2025 has prompted analysts to revise estimates upward. The company beat Q4 2024 EPS estimates and posted Q1 2025 results ahead of consensus. Morgan Stanley raised its price target to $90 from $80, reflecting confidence in Acushnet's execution and the durability of golf industry tailwinds.

The Bear Case

Tariffs are a significant margin headwind. Acushnet faces a projected $75 million gross tariff impact for 2025 and an estimated $70 million impact in 2026. Management has acknowledged that only about half of the projected tariff costs can be mitigated in the near term through pricing adjustments and supply chain shifts. This creates meaningful margin compression risk over the next 12-18 months — a particularly acute concern for a company whose moat depends partly on gross margin durability.

Valuation leaves little room for error. At a trailing P/E of roughly 20x and a forward P/E of 19x, Acushnet trades at a level that assumes continued execution. The earnings yield of 3.8% barely clears the Buffettology threshold, and the EV/FCF ratio of 28.5x suggests the market is pricing in sustained growth. Any stumble in revenue or margins could trigger a multiple contraction.

Consumer cyclical risk in a slowing economy. Golf equipment is a discretionary purchase, and Acushnet's products skew premium. If consumer spending softens — particularly among the affluent demographics that drive golf participation — demand for $50 golf balls and $200 golf shoes could soften. The company's Consumer Cyclical classification reflects this inherent sensitivity to economic cycles.

Competition and demographic headwinds loom. Increasing competition in premium golf equipment from brands like Callaway (Topgolf Callaway), TaylorMade, and emerging direct-to-consumer brands creates market saturation risk. Longer term, urbanization and the growth of alternative leisure activities could narrow the pool of younger golfers entering the sport, potentially capping the addressable market.

Analyst consensus is neutral. The median analyst price target of $80 sits below the recent trading price of approximately $84, implying modest downside. KeyBanc recently downgraded Acushnet to Sector Weight from Overweight. While Morgan Stanley remains more constructive, the overall consensus suggests limited near-term upside at current levels.

Valuation Overview

Acushnet's trailing P/E sits at approximately 20x, with a forward P/E of roughly 19x based on consensus 2026 EPS estimates of $3.54. The EV/EBITDA ratio of 14.1x is in line with consumer durables peers, and a recent analyst upgrade to a 13x EBITDA multiple (from 12.5x) reflects growing confidence in the business quality.

The earnings yield of 3.8% provides a slim premium over risk-free rates, suggesting that investors are paying close to fair value for the company's earnings stream. The EV/FCF ratio of 28.5x is elevated, though consistent with a company reinvesting in growth while maintaining aggressive buybacks.

Analyst price targets range from $67 to $90, with a median of $80 and a mean around $74. With the stock recently trading near $84, the consensus implies the stock is roughly fairly valued. Morgan Stanley's $90 target represents the bullish end, while the $67 low-end target reflects bear-case scenarios around tariff impacts and consumer spending weakness.

Compared to the broader Consumer Cyclical sector, Acushnet trades at a modest premium — justified, in theory, by its dominant market positions, consistent cash generation, and conservative balance sheet. The question is whether the premium is fully warranted or whether tariff-driven margin compression could temporarily reset expectations.

The Buffettology Verdict

Acushnet's perfect 9/9 Buffettology score reflects a business with genuine, measurable quality. A 27.7% ROE, 44% gross margins, 110% five-year earnings growth, and conservative 1.06x leverage create the financial fingerprint of a company with a real economic moat — exactly the kind of business Buffett's framework is designed to identify.

The moat here is tangible. Titleist and FootJoy don't just have market share — they have market dominance, reinforced by professional tour usage that creates aspirational demand. The 5.5% annual share count reduction compounds the value for patient shareholders.

The tension, as with many quality businesses, is price. The 3.8% earnings yield barely clears the valuation threshold, and near-term tariff headwinds could pressure the very margins that define the moat. For investors who believe golf participation will remain elevated and that Acushnet can navigate tariff costs through pricing power and supply chain adjustments, the stock offers a quality compounder at a fair price. For those more cautious about consumer cyclical risk and margin compression, the current valuation may not offer enough margin of safety.

Check GOLF on Buffett Score

Looking for more stocks that pass Buffett's test? Download the Vetted app to discover high-quality investment ideas scored against proven frameworks.