Wynn Resorts' Quiet Moat: Why Buffett's Framework Gives It an 8/9

What Is Wynn Resorts?

Wynn Resorts is one of the world's premier luxury casino and resort operators. Founded in 2002 by Steve Wynn and headquartered in Las Vegas, the company designs, develops, and operates integrated resorts that combine high-end gaming, hospitality, dining, entertainment, retail, and convention facilities. Its properties are positioned squarely at the top of the market — Wynn doesn't compete on volume or value; it competes on exclusivity.

The company operates across four segments. In Las Vegas, Wynn Las Vegas and Encore sit on the northern end of the Strip, drawing affluent leisure and convention travelers. In Macau — the world's largest gaming market — Wynn Palace and Wynn Macau cater to both mass-market and VIP gamblers. The Encore Boston Harbor rounds out the domestic portfolio. Macau has been the company's growth engine, with operating revenues there climbing 14.8% year-over-year in Q3 2025 to over $1 billion.

Wynn generated $7.14 billion in total operating revenue in 2025, essentially flat with 2024's $7.13 billion. Net income attributable to Wynn Resorts was $327 million in 2025, down from $501 million in 2024 — a decline driven by lower table game hold in Las Vegas and increased pre-opening costs for the company's most ambitious project yet: Wynn Al Marjan Island in the United Arab Emirates, slated to open in early 2027. That UAE resort represents a potentially transformative expansion into a new regulated gaming market.

How Wynn Resorts Scores on All 9 Buffettology Criteria

Wynn Resorts earns an impressive 8 out of 9 on the Buffettology scoring system — missing only on valuation. Here's how it performs on each criterion.

1. High Return on Equity — PASS

The threshold is 12%. Wynn's return on equity requires some context: the company has negative book equity of approximately -$1.1 billion, a result of aggressive share repurchases and the capital-intensive nature of building luxury resorts. When a highly profitable company has negative book equity — as do McDonald's, Starbucks, and other shareholder-friendly operators — the traditional ROE calculation becomes inverted. With $327 million in net income generated on a negative equity base, the Buffettology system recognizes that the underlying business is producing strong returns. The negative equity is a feature of capital allocation, not a sign of distress.

2. High Return on Invested Capital — PASS (9.8%)

ROIC measures how well a company uses all capital — debt and equity — to generate returns. The threshold is 9%. Wynn's 9.8% ROIC clears it. This is notable for a company with $12.2 billion in total debt, because it means the business is producing returns above its blended cost of capital even when accounting for the full debt burden. Every dollar invested in Wynn's properties generates nearly 10 cents of return — a solid figure for a capital-heavy luxury operator.

3. Cash Machine — PASS (~8.1% FCF/Assets)

This criterion checks whether the company generates meaningful free cash flow relative to its asset base. The threshold is 5%. Wynn generated $1.059 billion in free cash flow in 2024 on approximately $13 billion in total assets, yielding about 8.1%. That's well above the bar. Despite the massive upfront investment required to build and maintain luxury resorts, Wynn's properties throw off cash consistently — a testament to the pricing power that comes with being at the very top of the market.

4. Fair Valuation — FAIL (2.8% Earnings Yield)

The earnings yield (inverse of P/E) must exceed 3.5%. Wynn's earnings yield of 2.8% falls just short of the threshold. This translates to a trailing P/E of roughly 36x, reflecting the premium the market places on Wynn's luxury brand and growth prospects — particularly the UAE expansion. For context, the forward P/E drops to about 21.8x as analysts expect earnings to recover in 2026. This is the only criterion Wynn fails, and it's entirely a function of the stock's current market price relative to recent earnings.

5. Share Buybacks — PASS (-5.5% Share Dilution)

Buffett favors companies that shrink their share count. Wynn has reduced its outstanding shares by 5.5% year-over-year, bringing the count down to approximately 103 million. This aggressive buyback program — funded by the company's strong free cash flow — concentrates ownership and boosts per-share metrics over time. With 18.7% insider ownership, management's interests are well-aligned with shareholders.

6. Defensible Moat — PASS (41.4% Gross Margin)

Gross margins above 40% indicate pricing power and a competitive moat. Wynn's 41.4% gross margin passes the threshold. The moat here is multi-layered: gaming licenses are severely limited by government regulation in every jurisdiction where Wynn operates, the brand commands premium pricing that few competitors can match, building a comparable luxury resort requires billions in capital and years of construction, and the Wynn Rewards loyalty program creates switching costs. In Macau, only six concessionaires are licensed to operate — a government-mandated oligopoly.

7. Simple Business — PASS (Consumer Cyclical)

Wynn runs luxury casinos, hotels, restaurants, nightclubs, and spas. Customers gamble, book rooms, dine, shop, and attend shows. While the operations span multiple countries and currencies, the fundamental business model is simple: attract affluent customers to spectacular properties and monetize their spending across gaming and non-gaming categories. There's no speculative R&D or unproven technology.

8. Conservative Debt — PASS

Wynn carries $12.2 billion in total debt against $1.96 billion in cash, resulting in net debt of approximately $10.2 billion. The company's negative book equity means traditional debt-to-equity ratios aren't applicable in the conventional sense. However, it's worth noting that the Buffettology threshold evaluates the ratio of debt to equity, and when equity is negative — as it is for several iconic consumer brands that have bought back more stock than their retained earnings — the standard threshold check results in a pass. Investors should still be mindful of the absolute debt level: debt-to-EBITDA stands at 7.04x, and interest coverage is 1.79x. Management is actively managing the balance sheet, with recent refinancings improving the maturity profile.

9. Consistent Growth — PASS (Five-Year EPS Recovery)

Five-year net income growth must be positive. Wynn's earnings trajectory over the past five years tells a dramatic recovery story — from pandemic-era losses of over $10 per share in 2020 to positive earnings of $4.35 per share in 2024. The five-year average annual EPS growth rate is 31.7%, driven by the full reopening of Macau, the return of international travel, and operational improvements across all segments. While 2025 saw a pullback in net income to $327 million from $501 million, the long-term growth trend is firmly positive.

The Bull Case

The UAE is a game-changer. Wynn Al Marjan Island, opening in early 2027, will be the first integrated casino resort in the United Arab Emirates. This is a potentially enormous new market — the UAE attracts over 20 million visitors annually, and there's currently no legal gaming competition in the region. If the UAE resort performs anywhere near Macau-level economics, it could materially increase Wynn's enterprise value. The project represents the kind of first-mover advantage that Buffett has historically valued.

Macau's mass market is still growing. While VIP gaming has declined from its peak, Macau's mass-market segment — which carries higher margins for operators — continues to expand. Wynn's Q3 2025 Macau revenue hit $1.01 billion, up 14.8% year-over-year. The expansion of the Chairman's Club at Wynn Palace is designed to capture premium mass customers, a segment with better economics than either VIP or general mass. China's policy environment remains supportive of Macau tourism, and visitation hasn't fully recovered to pre-pandemic levels, leaving room for continued growth.

Convention and group business is strengthening. Wynn Las Vegas is building its convention and group booking pipeline, with expectations for growth in both room nights and rates into 2026. This higher-visibility revenue stream reduces reliance on volatile casino hold percentages and provides a more predictable base of hotel and food-and-beverage income.

New market opportunities abound. Beyond the UAE, Wynn is pursuing gaming licenses in New York (application expected in Q2 2026), monitoring Thailand's gambling legalization (regulations expected by end of 2025), and watching a potential Texas referendum. Any one of these could represent a significant new growth vector for the company.

Management is returning capital aggressively. A 5.5% reduction in share count plus a quarterly dividend reflects confidence in the business. With 18.7% insider ownership, the CEO and board are eating their own cooking. The aggressive buyback at current prices signals management's view that the stock is undervalued.

The Bear Case

Earnings are declining. Net income fell from $501 million in 2024 to $327 million in 2025 — a 35% drop. Q4 net income of $100 million was roughly a third of the $277 million posted in Q4 2024. EPS is expected to decline another 27.7% to $4.35 for fiscal 2025. The company has missed consensus EPS estimates in three of the last four quarters. While analysts expect a recovery to $5.32 in fiscal 2026, the near-term earnings trajectory is clearly negative.

Las Vegas is showing cracks. Casino revenue rose 8% in 2025, but hotel revenue fell 4% and food-and-beverage revenue dropped 2.5%. More concerning, table game win and win per unit per day both decreased more than 15% year-over-year in Q4. Planned Encore tower renovations starting in mid-May will disrupt operations across 2026 and 2027, temporarily reducing room inventory and gaming capacity.

Macau EBITDA is declining. Despite revenue growth, Wynn Palace's adjusted EBITDAR fell 7% in 2025 and Wynn Macau's declined 9%. Rising costs in Macau — including labor, concession fees, and compliance requirements under the new 10-year gaming license — are compressing margins. Macau remains subject to Chinese regulatory and travel policy risk, which has historically caused abrupt declines in gaming revenue.

The UAE bet is unproven. Wynn Al Marjan Island represents massive capital deployment in a jurisdiction with no track record of legal casino gaming. Regulatory frameworks are still being established, cultural acceptance of gambling is uncertain, and construction and pre-opening costs are already weighing on current earnings. If the project underperforms, it could become a multi-billion-dollar drag on the balance sheet.

Leverage is substantial. Total debt of $12.2 billion translates to a debt-to-EBITDA ratio of 7.04x. Interest coverage of just 1.79x means the company's operating income barely covers its interest expense. The beta of 1.01 is moderate, but the underlying financial leverage amplifies both upside and downside outcomes. If any major property underperforms or macro conditions deteriorate, the debt load leaves limited margin for error.

Valuation Overview

Wynn trades at a trailing P/E of roughly 36x and a forward P/E of about 21.8x, reflecting expectations that earnings will recover in 2026. The 2025 estimated P/E is 23.6x, dropping to 18.5x for 2026 as analysts forecast EPS growth of 22.3% to $5.32.

On an EV/EBITDA basis, Wynn trades at 12.64x — higher than peer Caesars Entertainment (8.25x) but reflective of Wynn's luxury positioning and growth pipeline. The price-to-sales ratio of 1.65x is moderate for a premium hospitality brand.

Analyst sentiment is overwhelmingly positive. Of 16 analysts covering the stock, 14 rate it a "Strong Buy" and one a "Moderate Buy," with just one "Hold." The median price target is $120.75, with a range of $100 to $135. The average target of $143.50 implies roughly 25% upside from the current share price near $114. Alpha Spread's intrinsic value estimate of $150.20 suggests the stock is undervalued by approximately 24%.

The valuation disconnect is worth noting: analysts and intrinsic value models see meaningful upside, but the Buffettology framework demands a higher earnings yield than the stock currently offers. This is a case where a quality business trades at a quality premium — and Buffett's framework says the premium is still too high.

The Buffettology Verdict

Wynn Resorts' 8/9 Buffettology score places it in elite company. The business passes on nearly every quality test Buffett's framework applies: it generates strong free cash flow, earns above its cost of capital, operates in a simple and understandable industry, benefits from deep regulatory moats, and returns capital to shareholders through aggressive buybacks.

The single failure — fair valuation — is arguably the most Buffett-like criterion to miss. Warren Buffett has always said he'd rather buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price, but he has never said he'd pay any price. At 36x trailing earnings, Wynn is priced for the growth it's expected to deliver, particularly from the UAE expansion. If that growth materializes and the forward P/E compresses toward the mid-teens, the stock could pass all nine criteria.

For now, Wynn Resorts is a textbook example of a high-quality business where the only question is price. The moat is real, the cash generation is strong, and the growth pipeline is the most exciting in the gaming industry. Whether the current valuation makes it a compelling investment depends on your confidence in the UAE bet and Macau's continued recovery.

Check WYNN on Buffett Score

Want to find stocks that earn a perfect Buffettology score? Download the Vetted app to explore detailed Buffettology analysis across thousands of stocks, plus scores from multiple expert investment strategies.